Dyskusja Wikipedysty:Djiggy
Z Wikipedii
Welcome to polish wikipedia! If don't understand polish you can use {{user pl-0}} template on your user page. Greetings, Herr Kriss 22:58, 26 paź 2006 (CEST)
[edytuj] AfD, etc
As far as Mr. Anatoly is concerned, it is my understanding that the result on de.wiki was delete, so this might be not a good way to justify your requests to keep it here. Unless I'm mistaken, there was no formal voting on Ms. Gal on that Wikipedia.
Regardless of the time and effort you might have invested in preparing these articles, they seem to (at best!) fail to establish the notability of the characters they describe; and by most standards, also fail verifiability tests. Verifiability and notability are two of the founding principles of Wikipedia, and it is the author's duty to take care of this (or accept that Wikipedia is not the right project for this type of material). Personally, I also find it hard to accept your version of the events, given the timing and style of your translations. -- (lcamtuf)° 01:01, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- I find absolutely no evidence of the article being restored on de.wiki by a sysop. Quite the opposite, it seems that the article was deleted as a result of AfD, and then deleted again after you attempted to re-create it under the same name. You then created it under a different name to avoid deletion. -- (lcamtuf)° 01:25, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- There is absolutely no data to support your claim. -- (lcamtuf)° 01:35, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- This log is for a different page, but indeed, the story is different there. Still, it only shows that on 16/01/2006 your article was deleted after a voting, you attempted to re-create it on 19/01/2006, and it was again deleted; and then on 19/01/2006 you created it under a different name, after which one of the administrators also deleted it. Then the same administrator restored this page several hours later, but there seems to be no immediate explanation as to why he did it. -- (lcamtuf)° 02:28, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- Frankly, at this point, I give up. It is my strong and continuing belief that you're either Ms. Gal Rasche, or her associate, and that these translations were prepared not out of the desire to help build Wikipedia, but for the purpose of promoting the author. Alas, navigating through a maze of poorly documented deletions, restores and moves on various Wikipedias only makes me draw conclusions that are often premature and soon invalidated by further research, and in general quite unnecessary as far as establishing the notability of the article on pl.wiki and en.wiki goes; I back off; we'll see how it unfolds. If I misjudged you or managed to misinterpret any facts, please accept my apologies. -- (lcamtuf)° 03:09, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- This log is for a different page, but indeed, the story is different there. Still, it only shows that on 16/01/2006 your article was deleted after a voting, you attempted to re-create it on 19/01/2006, and it was again deleted; and then on 19/01/2006 you created it under a different name, after which one of the administrators also deleted it. Then the same administrator restored this page several hours later, but there seems to be no immediate explanation as to why he did it. -- (lcamtuf)° 02:28, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
- There is absolutely no data to support your claim. -- (lcamtuf)° 01:35, 30 paź 2006 (CET)
